Quick Answer
Diastasis recti is a widening of the connective tissue between your abdominal muscles, with no actual opening in the abdominal wall, so nothing can become trapped there. An umbilical hernia is a genuine gap at or near your belly button, which means fat or bowel can push through it, and in adults that gap doesn’t usually close on its own. The two can look similar from the outside, and can happen together, but a GP or surgeon can usually tell them apart on examination, sometimes with an ultrasound if it isn’t obvious. If you have a new bulge near your navel, it is worth getting checked rather than guessing, especially if it is painful, doesn’t soften when you lie flat, or comes with nausea or vomiting.
Something I hear often from women in my classes, usually said half apologetically, is some version of “I think my diastasis has got worse, there’s a lump now.” Most of the time what they are describing really is diastasis recti, the midline softening and doming that so many postpartum bodies carry for a while. But every so often, when I ask a few more questions, what they are describing is actually something else sitting in the exact same patch of skin: an umbilical hernia. Nobody told them these were two different things, so why would they think to separate them.
It matters because they are not managed the same way. One is something a structured, pressure-aware exercise approach can genuinely help. The other, in an adult, is a structural problem that exercise cannot close, and that usually needs a surgeon’s opinion. Getting the two confused isn’t anyone’s fault. Getting the distinction clear is the whole point of this guide.
What’s Actually Different Between Them
If it helps to picture it, think of the connective tissue running down the midline of your abdomen, the linea alba, as a piece of fabric. During pregnancy, that fabric stretches to make room, and in diastasis recti, it stays stretched afterwards, wider than before, but still one continuous piece. There is no actual hole, just a softer, wider gap, which is why pressing on it feels more like jelly than like an edge. An umbilical hernia is a different kind of problem: it’s a genuine break in that fabric, almost always at the belly button itself, because that’s a natural weak point left over from where your umbilical cord once passed through. Through that real gap, a bit of fat or a loop of bowel can actually push forward. That’s a useful way to picture the difference, but it isn’t a substitute for an actual examination, since both sit in the same small area and can look confusingly alike from the outside.
A 2021 paper in the journal Hernia on diagnosing diastasis recti makes the same point clinically: a thorough history and physical examination is usually enough to diagnose diastasis recti on its own, but working out whether a hernia is also present within that diastasis is the detail that most affects what happens next, since that’s what decides whether surgery needs to be considered at all (Tung & Towfigh, 2021). A separate, larger 2025 review in the same journal notes that a midline gap of 2cm or more is generally treated as clinically significant, and that this threshold matters even more when a hernia exists alongside it, because the two conditions are frequently assessed and classified together rather than in isolation (Du et al., 2025).
How Each One Is Actually Diagnosed
The self-check most women already know is a reasonable starting point. Lying on your back with your knees bent, lift your head and shoulders slightly off the floor as if starting a sit-up, and use your fingertips to feel along the midline above and below your belly button. With diastasis recti, you’re feeling for a gap between the two muscle bands, and often a soft doming or coning along that line as you lift. A gap of around two finger-widths, roughly 2cm, is the rough threshold clinicians use (our full guide to checking for diastasis recti walks through this test in more detail).
Where a hernia is involved, the feel tends to be different: more of a firm, localised lump right at or just beside the navel, rather than an even softness along the whole midline, and it may bulge more noticeably when you cough, strain, or stand up, and ease or disappear when you lie flat and relax. None of this adds up to a diagnosis on its own. The only way to know for certain, especially when the two sit this close together, is a proper examination, and your GP may use ultrasound to confirm what’s actually there if it isn’t obvious by feel alone.
Can You Have Both at Once?
Yes, and it’s genuinely common, not a rare overlap. The same stretching of the linea alba that produces diastasis recti also weakens the natural ring of tissue around the belly button, which is exactly where an umbilical hernia tends to form. In my own work with postnatal women, I see this combination fairly often: a wide, soft midline gap with one small, firmer lump sitting inside it at the navel. Clinically, this is recognised too. Surgeons specifically plan hernia repair differently when it sits inside a wider diastasis, because the surrounding tissue is already under more strain than it would be for a hernia on its own (Tung & Towfigh, 2021).
What’s Safe to Do While You Figure This Out
Gentle daily movement is not automatically something to avoid while you wait for an assessment, and you don’t need to brace yourself still until a letter arrives. What’s worth being honest about is what exercise can and can’t do for each condition. For diastasis recti on its own, structured core and pressure-management work has a real, evidence-backed place. In my experience teaching Hypopressives, many women see a genuine, sometimes substantial, narrowing of a diastasis gap with consistent practice, alongside better pressure control more broadly. Our guide to diastasis recti exercises using Hypopressives goes into that in depth.
An umbilical hernia is a different story, and I want to be straightforward about it rather than soften it: no breathing technique, Hypopressives included, closes an actual gap in the abdominal wall. The NHS is clear that in adults, an umbilical hernia is unlikely to get better by itself, and surgery is the usual recommendation. If you already know you have a hernia, the apnea, or breath-hold, phase of full Hypopressives practice is also worth checking with your GP or surgeon before starting, for the same reason it’s flagged for hiatal and inguinal hernias: it briefly raises pressure through the abdominal wall, and I’d rather you ask first than assume. Our article on Hypopressives contraindications covers this in more detail. None of this means you’ve done anything wrong by exercising, or that movement caused the hernia. It just means a true hernia needs a surgeon’s input, not a different breathing pattern.
What to Mention at Your GP Appointment
A few specific details tend to get you a clearer answer than describing “a lump” in general. It can help to go in ready to say:
- “The bulge has been there since [roughly when], and it has/hasn’t changed since.”
- “It gets more noticeable when I cough, strain, or stand for a while.”
- “It does/doesn’t go away or soften when I lie flat and relax.”
- “I’ve also noticed [any other symptoms, such as tenderness, bloating, or a dragging feeling].”
- “I’m currently doing, or considering, core and pelvic floor exercise, including Hypopressives. Is that something I should hold off on until this is assessed?”
When to Seek Assessment
This guide is educational and cannot tell you what’s actually happening in your own body. Any new bulge near your belly button is worth having checked by a GP, even without alarming symptoms, simply because diastasis recti and umbilical hernia genuinely need different management and can’t always be told apart with confidence from the outside. Book an appointment reasonably soon, rather than waiting, if the bulge is tender, doesn’t soften when you lie down, or has grown noticeably.
Seek urgent medical attention, via NHS 111 or A&E, if the bulge becomes suddenly very painful and doesn’t ease, if the skin over it changes colour, or if it comes with nausea, vomiting, or an inability to pass wind or stool. These can be signs that a hernia has become trapped or lost its blood supply, which is a genuine medical emergency and not something to wait out at home.
If you’d like the fuller picture on diastasis recti itself, including how to check for it properly and what helps it heal, our full guide to diastasis recti is the place to start. For hernias more broadly, including the other types and how they’re typically managed, our guide to hernias covers that ground.
Sources
- NHS: Umbilical hernia, symptoms, causes, treatment and emergency warning signs
- NHS: Hernia, general symptoms and when to get urgent help
- Cleveland Clinic: Diastasis recti, diagnosis, self-check and management
- Tung & Towfigh (2021): Diagnostic techniques for diastasis recti, Hernia
- Du et al. (2025): Diastasis recti abdominis, a comprehensive review, Hernia



